I continue to be shocked at how quiet and chilly the reaction to this recording has been. Have all of Audra's fans disappeared suddenly? This was not what happened when the LuPone Gypsy was released.
Also, RE: the earlier comment about LuPone's recording, I actually think Patti's performance on record is incredibly strong and the moments of ego and narcissism (e.g. Rose's Turn) are clearly in service of the character. Sometimes her live performance drifted a little (e.g. if you listen to the final performance I don't think she was as disciplined) - but I suspect that she was in the studio taking a lot of direction from Sondheim to turn out that performance (in a similar way Bernadette's "Losing My Mind" was a little more fragile and emotional on stage in Follies but then in the studio was a very clean musical performance. I understand that Sondheim is heavy handed in the studio. I wonder if we are missing something without him).
Give me claws and a hunch, just away from this bunch.