HAMILTON Principal Cast Replacements- Page 74

[MatthewS1]

Posted: 8/16/24 at 12:31pm

DottieD'Luscia said: "Stephanie Umoh is the new Angelica. She's fine, just not my favorite in the role. I saw her on tour a few years ago. I wish Ta'Rea Campbell was in it. She's phenomenal as Angelica."

Ta’Rea was my first Angelica in an otherwise meh cast in St. Louis. Satisfied was one of the best parts of the show. We had understudies for Hamilton, Burr, and Laf/Jeff and the chemistry between the male leads was just not there. Our Eliza was also just okay. But Ta’Rea? Insane

[DottieD'Luscia]

Posted: 8/16/24 at 12:38pm

There were a lot of principal male absences when I saw the tour in DC 2 years ago.  Saw the 2nd cover for Burr.  Not good at all!!  Same thing happened when I saw the tour in Baltimore in 2019 (different Burr cover).

[Quinn Wilson]

Posted: 8/16/24 at 6:13pm

MatthewS1 said: "DottieD'Luscia said: "Stephanie Umoh is the new Angelica. She's fine, just not my favorite in the role. I saw her on tour a few years ago. I wish Ta'Rea Campbell was in it. She's phenomenal as Angelica."

Ta’Rea was my first Angelica in an otherwise meh cast in St. Louis. Satisfied was one of the best parts of the show. We had understudies for Hamilton, Burr, and Laf/Jeff and the chemistry between the male leads was just not there. Our Eliza was also just okay. But Ta’Rea? Insane"

Did you see the very first iteration of the Phillip tour? I agree about the male leads but I thought Shoba Narayan and Nyla Sostre were just as good as T’area.

[PipingHotPiccolo]

Posted: 8/16/24 at 6:50pm

Hasnt Umoh played the role on Broadway before?

[QueenTwinnied]

Posted: 8/17/24 at 1:04am

DottieD'Luscia said: "Stephanie Umoh is the new Angelica. She's fine, just not my favorite in the role. I saw her on tour a few years ago. I wish Ta'Rea Campbell was in it. She's phenomenal as Angelica."

Totally agree. I thought Ta'Rea was phenomenal and she has a killer voice. I was hoping she was the replacement.

[QueenTwinnied]

Posted: 8/17/24 at 1:05am

PipingHotPiccolo said: "Hasnt Umoh played the role on Broadway before?"

Yes, if I recall correctly she played Angelica for a short time while Jennie Harney-Fleming was on leave/break.

[MatthewS1]

Posted: 8/17/24 at 9:37pm

Quinn Wilson said: "Did you see the very first iteration of the Phillip tour? I agree about the male leads but I thought Shoba Narayan and Nyla Sostre were just as good as T’area."

I did not- my first Eliza just ended her run on Broadway. I thought she was fine. Burn didn’t have the emotional punch it needed.

I saw the tour again in Chicago in January, and I can’t believe I’m saying this, but that Eliza was sleepwalking through the role. She genuinely did not looked like she cared about being on stage. She left the tour a few weeks later in a huge cast change- maybe she was burnt out but it really took me out of the show. I’ve seen a bunch of similar comments in other places about her performance…

Updated On: 8/17/24 at 09:37 PM

[MatthewS1]

Posted: 8/19/24 at 2:17pm

Tamar Greene will be starring in Stages St. Louis’ production of Ragtime as Coalhouse Walker Jr. His son is playing Coalhouse III and his wife is the understudy for Sarah. Full cast drops at 4 pm EST. 

Many of you may remember that a video of Tamar singing Wheels of a Dream to his son went viral last year. It’s a dream role of his, and as a current St. Louis resident I feel so fortunate that we get to steal him from NY for a few months!! The production runs September 20 - October 20th, so he will probably be back in Hamilton in late October.

[DottieD'Luscia]

Posted: 8/19/24 at 3:15pm

Tamar will be a wonderful Coalhouse!

[MatthewS1]

Posted: 8/19/24 at 4:15pm

Just announced that Shereen Pimentel is Sarah, which explains why she is leaving Cats. This is going to be a not-to-be-missed production if you’re in the Midwest!!

[GiantsInTheSky2]

Posted: 8/26/24 at 11:02am

Nicholas Christopher is playing George Washington August 27th through October 20th, according to his IG story. 

[MatthewS1]

Posted: 9/4/24 at 1:14am

Just got back from seeing the new Angelica tour in St. Louis. It’s my 3rd time seeing the show live and this is without a doubt the best cast I’ve seen. I would expect many of the principals to eventually transfer to Broadway. Eliza, Washington, and Burr were all standouts. Justin Sargent stole the show as KGIII and delivered the best You’ll Be Back I’ve ever heard. I can’t recommend the tour enough, even if you have seen the show before

[Elphaba2019]

Posted: 10/2/24 at 11:15pm

How is the Broadway cast currently specifically Trey Curtis as Hamilton and Jared Dixon as Burr? I am debating between seeing this or Wicked for the 10th Time I really want to see Mary Kate Morrisey but also am dying to see Hamilton but might want to wait for a new cast. The only person I know of in this cast is Nicholas Christopher. 

[lastmidnights]

Posted: 9/8/25 at 2:07pm

Has anyone seen the show recently and can they comment on the quality of the new cast? Just want to manage my expectations for when I see it again with LOJ. Last time I went was in 2017, and I really disliked Munoz, Lawson, Gonzalez. I was shocked at how poor those performances were for a hit show only 2 years into the run. 

[EDSOSLO858]

Posted: 9/9/25 at 4:48pm

Who'll be there in the room where it happens tonight for Leslie's return?

[Jarethan]

Posted: 9/10/25 at 12:43am

I have seen Hamilton live 5 times, only once with the original cast, and I have seen it on Disney a few times.

I decided to see the movie today to see if it made a difference on a big screen, as purported.  My opinion: I thought it represented a sizable improvement over watching it on my TV (my home TV is 65 inches, so not huge but certainly not small, and it has a good if not outstanding sound system).

Here is the thing that I concluded, however, after this latest viewing. I am not sure there is any point in my paying to see it live again, when there is such an amazing record of the original cast.  I have seen very talented people in the other live viewings, but none have come close to the individual performances of Daveed Diggs, Christopher Jackson, Phillipa Soo or Renee Elise Goldsberry.  While that may not be true of LMM's performance (at least one I saw was as good, perhaps better), but he will always score bonus points as author and originator of the role. ( For reasons I can not articulate, Leslie Odom Jr's. performance has never bowled me over).

 

[EDSOSLO858]

Posted: 1/7/26 at 3:48pm

Edred Utomi will take over as Alexander Hamilton in the Broadway company starting tonight, through May 10. 

[QueenTwinnied]

Posted: 1/8/26 at 3:39am

Very happy for Edred! He’s so talented

I saw him play Alexander many years ago (like 2018) soon after he joined the national tour as Standby. 

[PipingHotPiccolo]

Posted: 1/8/26 at 9:47am

EDSOSLO858 said: "Edred Utomi will take over as Alexander Hamilton in the Broadway companystarting tonight, through May 10."

With his wife next door, good for them.

But this feels sudden- was who was playing Hamilton yesterday?

[witchoftheeast2]

Posted: 1/8/26 at 10:09am

I hope Trey Curtis's exit wasn't due to the rude comments people made about his performance online. I saw him several times and always loved him. People on Tiktok were not as kind. I hope it was just because his contract was up.

[DottieD'Luscia]

Posted: 1/8/26 at 10:28am

Edred is wonderful as Hamilton.  I saw him numerous times on tour 2018 and 2019.  Surprised his engagement isn't longer.  Out of all the Hamilton's I've seen, he's definitely my favorite.

Trey Curtis announced on IG in December that he was departing the show.  He was out the last time I saw the show two years ago. Bryson Bruce played Hamilton that day.  I liked him.  Trey had been with the Broadway company for 2 years, so I'm thinking he chose to leave. 

Tamar Greene leaves on the 25th.  Hands down my favorite Washington.  Haven't heard who will be replacing him.

Updated On: 1/8/26 at 10:28 AM

[witchoftheeast2]

Posted: 1/8/26 at 4:22pm

DottieD'Luscia said: "Edred is wonderful as Hamilton. I saw him numerous times on tour 2018 and 2019. Surprised his engagement isn't longer. Out of all the Hamilton's I've seen, he's definitely my favorite.

Trey Curtis announced on IG in December that he was departing the show. He was out the last time I saw the show two years ago. Bryson Bruce played Hamilton that day. I liked him.Trey had been with the Broadway company for 2 years, so I'm thinking he chose to leave.

Tamar Greene leaves on the 25th. Hands down my favorite Washington. Haven't heard who will be replacing him."

With Leslie Odom Jr. doing a second stint Christopher Jackson would be amazing but that wouldn't ever happen