I saw this show this past Saturday and, unfortunately, I don’t think it’s very good. It’s frustrating because there’s such a rich foundation for a show, yet scene after scene it walks up to something interesting and then backs away or diffuses the tension off-stage and fills us in later (Mel’s conflict at work, Tommy’s driver’s license test, Caroline’s language exam, Caroline and Jessica’s fight, whatever the hell is going on with Drew’s parents). It’s like the show is afraid of conflict, but that’s where the real drama lies. Instead, we’re left with thinly sketched characters and very low stakes.
However, I think the biggest sin is the outsized focus on the Amigos. Why would the writers think any of us care about Ashley’s half baked Juilliard dilemma, and why is she given two songs about it (and, in a very bad look, is the recipient of an uplifting anthem in Act II)? The show would improve immediately by excising the character completely. Then there’s Samayoa, who I think is actively bad, as Dr. Amigo. His character decrees how much he doesn’t want the focus to be on him and yet the show often feels like it is very much about him (a whole scene devoted to an unsuccessful date; why?). The kids should be the stars.
A few bright spots: Liam Pierce is fantastic, Connor Tague is very charming, and “Getting Ready For the Dance” is genuinely effective. It just feels like such a missed opportunity.