I enjoyed this quite a bit today, but I do think it feels like it's in previews (in that I could definitely see changes being made). I actually kind of liked that the first act didn't have stakes, as I found it pretty interesting to just see the kids interacting with each other and with Dr. Amigo, and I almost wish the whole show was just about them in group therapy learning the skills they needed. The concept of the dance felt like it was introduced somewhat abruptly, but it was also interesting to see how that affected the different characters and what approaches each one took. The first act closer felt a little strange because it seemed like it was trying to make an event seem like a big deal just to have something to close on, but it didn't feel like that big to me, especially compared to some of the dramatic stakes in the second act (which in some cases felt like they were just a wrench thrown in for the sake of having stakes).
But I thought the show did a wonderful job of introducing each of the characters and letting them be fully realized (most of them at least). In particular, I liked how Dr. Amigo was clearly a great person to be leading this group, but also made his own missteps, and you could see him coming up with different ideas on the fly for trying new methods. I would've liked to see more about the relationships between some of the core 7, and it was difficult to keep track of how old each one was (before seeing the show I assumed everyone was in high school, but that was not the case).
I think the music serves the piece, but none of the melodies really jumped out at me. They were different enough and had interesting enough orchestration that I enjoyed them while they happened, but there weren't any songs I really had a desire to listen to again. Some of the lyrics felt a bit basic, and for a lot of the rhymes I could complete the line in my head before they said it (which isn't something that I notice a lot), but I enjoyed the sentiment of a lot of them.
Spoiler thoughts regarding some of the side plots:
Click Here To Toggle Spoiler Content
I also thought Dr. Amigo's romance plotline needed to go. I can see how they want to show him making a mistake, but it doesn't really serve the story, and the real mistake is the one with the blogger and not with the newspaper reporter.
I thought the daughter's plotline was interesting though and also provided a good foil to the main dance plotline. It's clear that she's good at what she does in helping out at the center, and I think it's nice to have a moment where "normal" people run into the same sorts of issues with growing up and figuring out what path to take forwards and knowing what to do. Her song "Life Interrupts" I think was good both for her but also as meta-commentary that they can prepare all they want but you never know what will happen. And I think that Dr. Amigo being unable to understand her want to no longer attend Julliard fits in nicely with how he treats Drew who decided not to go to Michigan and how his personal life can sometimes interfere with his clients.
I don't know that we needed the plotlines of the parents, but I thought the song "Getting Ready for the Dance" was pretty sweet, and it was nice to see the parents as human too, ones who didn't necessarily know what they were doing either and just wanted the best for their kids.
Overall, I thought the show was really sweet and I definitely had tears in my eyes multiple times through the course of the show.