BroadwayBoy0924 said: "I think I am in the minority among those who have posted on this thread...I really loved this musical, I thought the cast was excellent and this show has great potential. The show really moved me and I was bawling for pretty much the last twenty minutes straight. I thought Building Momentum and So Much in Common were excellent, as well as Slow Dancing. I really hope the critics are kind to this show since I think they really need a boost.
I do agree that there are areas that could use improvement/changes. The second act was definitely stronger. I enjoyed Getting Ready for the Dance. I think that song was really sweet. So I do feel like there is a place for the parents, but maybe just a little less. Also maybe just Caroline, Jessica, and Marideth's parents and drop the others. I can't recall who the other parents were that popped up, but felt unnecessary. The storyline with Mr. Amigos and the female reporter was kind of cringy and unnecessary. I think they could've just shown how much Mr. Amigos admired her for her quality of work and didn't need to go further with that.
The standouts of the show were clearly the 7 "kids" and Mr. Amigos. They could definitely take out some filler from the other cast.
My one biggest note with the music is to cut down the references to Ohio. It felt overdone and cheesy. I loved Kimberly Akimbo last year and they sang "in New Jersey" frequently, but it worked for them. The frequent "Ohio" lyrics felt like a carbon copy and predictable. I hope the Directors/Producers/etc can make some adjustments before opening nights as I really want this show to be set up for success."
I'm with you - I thought it was wonderful, and the audience I saw it with loved it. It was the most actively responsive audience I was part of out of the six shows I saw over the weekend. The music doesn't really break any molds innovation-wise, but the songs are all good. The book has some missteps, but it ultimately comes to a conclusion that is both sweet and empowering. The young cast is fantastic, and I also like how they humanized the adults as well. I think this show has the potential to be a real crowdpleaser with reach outside of Broadway circles.
One thing I want to bring up is the subplot involving Mr. Amigos and the reporter. It's definitely flawed in its execution, but I can see why it's there:
Click Here To Toggle Spoiler Content
Mr. Amigos's arc is one of him realizing he has a habit of missing the forest for the trees, and sometimes takes an overly paternal view of his clients (not to mention his daughter) rather than allowing them to make their own decisions on their own terms. The subplot involving the press (it must be mentioned that this was completely made up for the musical and isn't part of the documentary at all) demonstrates some of these character flaws because he insists the press talk to him rather than the clients, and show how the flattery from both as well as his attraction to the reporter means he misses how the blogger is coming to the wrong conclusions.
Rather than being a savior narrative, it shows how people come to tell stories that way and why they aren't helpful (and are often insulting) to the communities they are ostensibly about
Again, it could have be executed better, but as it stands I think the conclusion is ultimately worth the sometimes-rocky road it takes to get there.