Sutton herself said after Anything Goes that almost every scene for which she was remembered featured her tap-dancing. One of the main reasons she took on Violet was to test herself in a serious role in which she was not always grinning ear-to-ear. I guess she succeeded, given the Tony nomination and strong reviews.
I guess that she will have to prove herself again in Music Man. Which of these Marians is not like the others?
Barbara Cook, Shirley Jones, Rebecca Luker, Kristin Chenoweth and the 44 year old Foster? I wouldn't bet against Sutton. She is one of those who succeeds at just about everything she tries. And it doesn't hurt that she's so likeable.
No one, however, has every gift at the same level. Looking over the many songs that she has recorded, I think that I see a pretty small portion of them representing the the typical romantic ballads that so many others have covered. No "Someone to Watch Over Me," "All the Things You Are," "Just the Way You Look Tonight," "I'll Be Seeing You," "Smoke Gets in Your Eyes," etc. etc. Or bluesy songs like "The Man That Got Away," or "One For My Baby."
It does bother me a little that there are many talented young actresses around in their prime who are doing voice-overs for animated films instead of being cast in great roles from shows new and revived. But that's not Sutton's fault.