Ever since the other day when I posted on the Encores thread that I thought Sutton Foster would be a good choice to do the show I've been listening to it non stop. Get Patti or Carol in there as the Queen and Cheyenne as Prince Dauntless and you'll get a good audience, I think.
It's been almost 15 years since the last one (WOW) and it's the kind of show that usually does well, isn't it?
I am legit all over Patti or Carol as the Queen. AAA+++, Jordan.
It's most probably way too small of a part for Patti to even consider but she would knock it out of the park.
This could go in the Lunt-Fontanne after the Addams Family closes, and its a kids show. Quadruple plus.
and one of the characters is going to HAVE a kid!
What the WHAT?!
It might be a little on the small side, but I can still think it's a good idea.
I actually also like the idea of Beth Leavel as the Queen.
Patti has taken small roles in concert productions before. She played Yvonne/Blair Daniels in Sunday at Ravinia.
"I actually also like the idea of Beth Leavel as the Queen."
GAY GASP!
^ a pearl clutching gasp or one of recognition of total brilliance?
Broadway Legend Joined: 8/14/07
I said this two Years ago.
Patti Lupone and Sutton.
the production would make millions.
ew WHY
although Foster would be charming and the show could be cast to high hell, this high school theatre staple has merely an above average book and a lame score. Let it stay dead.
and honestly, what kinda kids these day care about the princess and the pea?
I do have to say that Kathleen Marshall's much edited movie is delightful though, well-cast and entertaining. it works better as such a 90 minute distraction than a full 2 hour musical with lame songs like "Very Soft Shoes"
Why?
Because it's one of my favorite shows and I want to see a full scale revival of it and I'm sure a lot of other people would, also.
And Kathleen Marshall's movie was a mess. A hot tranny mess.
The score to MATTRESS is much better than some of the crap people are writing nowadays.
I'd take a revival of this to the upcoming Addams Family.
The show is LOW comedy akin to "Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum." I'd get Lea Delaria instead of Foster who was great in the 42nd Street Moon production in 2005. I couldn't picture Carol Burnett in her prime(as well as the creators original choice Nancy Walker) playing any of Foster's roles (eh maybe SHREK) anymore than I can see Sutton as Winifred or Hildy. The role calls for a loud larger than life overpowering yet lovable buffoon. Sarah Jessica Parker didn't fit that bill either.
Kritzer
Borle
and
Jan Maxwell
Broadway Legend Joined: 7/28/05
Why on earth would you cast Cheyenne as Prince Dauntless? He'd be a great Sir Harry, though!
I love the recording with Lewis Cleale, SJP, Krakowsky, etc.
Love some of these ideas and this show.
Leavel as Queen? Check
Cheyenne as Harry? Check
Borle as Dauntless? CHECK
Sutton as Fred? Check
But I don't think this is a huge attention getter. It's between a rock and a hard place: children's theatre story and dealing with pre marital sex/pregnancy. I know it's not ground breaking or edgy....but it's not exactly KID friendly.
As phenomenal as Sutton would be..... for a BIG name they should have Ellen as Winnifred!!!! She'd be incredible!!
Broadway Legend Joined: 2/20/04
Ellen? She's 50.
mattress shouldn't be revived forthe same reason Funny Girl shouldn't be revived. Broadway lacks that bigger-than-life comedienne with a powerful voice.
Bump. 10 years later and I still want this.
Broadway Legend Joined: 1/25/20
Annaleigh Ashford? Sarah Stiles? Jessie Mueller?
Mueller would be fun. But honestly I still kinda want Sutton.
How’s the album with Sarah Jessica Parker? Is it worth a listen?
I love it. But then again, I loved the whole production and never understood the negative reviews it got.
Videos