bk said: "But all the people complaining about the dreary old book haven't seen the original production. My favorite, of course, is when people, in order to look like they know whereof they speak, lie and say they did, even though one later finds out they weren't even born then :) (And yes, that's happened.) The book scenes played brilliantly in the original production because the actors were amazing, spoke the lines well, and had co-directors who knew what they were doing. I don't want to hear criticisms of the book based on any of the revivals because there has yet to be a revival that's come anywhere near the original production - maybe London this year will change that - I remain ever hopeful. But I just roll my eyes at the complainers of the book who then admit they are basing those complaints on the recent revival or the Roundabout revival - neither of which DID the original book. And it's not enough to just read the old published script - the actors and directors made it work beautifully. I will defend it forever. "
BK, you are raising an interesting point.
I certainly didn't see the original production of FOLLIES so I can't say if the book worked in that production or not.
But the implication of what you are saying is still unpersuasive. It seems that what you are suggesting is that unless one saw the original production, one can't possibly have an opinion about FOLLIES. Taking to absurd levels, it might follow from your suggestion that there is no reason for anyone to have any opinion about any work unless one saw its original production. And, taken one step further, since it is often the case that works receive what to many is their definitive due not in their original productions but in a subsequent one, that one can't reach a valid opinion about the worth of a libretto unless one has seen every rendition of the show. Which is an impractial hypothesis, as no one ever sees every rendition of a show since shows continue to be produced and reinterpreted (for better or for worse and usually for both) long after each of us our dead.
Isn't a better way to think about this that we all see what we see, think what we think, and, at our best, try to keep an open mind about the value of a work as we and the various interpreters of a work revisit it?
I know I try to do that. My opinion of several shows - and as it happens, many Sondheim musicals - has changed over the years for the better because I've seen what I felt were productions which finally "got" it in a way that made it gel for me. Sometimes this is a result of how I've changed, often it's a result of how the work has been interpreted and presented, and sometimes it's been a combination of the two.
While I have yet to see that "come-to-Weissman" moment happen with FOLLIES, I am certainly willing to keep an open mind and hope that one day this musical finally breaks through for me. In fact, at present, I'm somewhat optimistic from reports from London that the National's production might achieve that.
But what I can't agree with, if in fact you are suggesting it, is that if one hasn't seen either the original of FOLLIES, or for that matter any apotheosis-considered production of a any musical, that one has no authority to speak about the value of the work based on one's own experiences of it.
Updated On: 8/28/17 at 09:40 AM