I used to work at the school during the "Golden Years" (the 80's-- but I keep in touch). Their program has always focused on getting work.
You take from it what you make of it.
Many of the students we cut ("fired") from the program came back to thank us: either they got jobs or realized this business was not for them.
That is what the program used to try to teach. Either you put in the intense work necessary for the program or you get cut. Either way you begin to learn the truth about the "professional theater"!
If you can't handle the program--you can't handle the biz.
However, many of the people we would cut went on to great careers. We would cut people for many reasons: (1.) couldn't handle the work/pressure (2.) were already ready to audition. (3.) we wanted to see them prove us wrong!--many did!!!! (it's the "kick-in-the-ass" moment people sometimes need!)
One of the things the staff were told by management was to remember: as a teacher you are the employer---anyone of your students could very well become your employer.
There is no democracy in theater. Tables turn.
The students who understood/understand this have become working actors.
And that's the point. Not fame. But working...
Auditioning is a key component to AMDA's strategy. They can help you get the job. YOU have to keep it and prove you are capable. The school gives you the tools to do it.
==
I used to work in a casting office on Broadway. It was always clear who came from the AMDA program. They had confidence and awareness of their "product" (i.e. knowing who and what you are and can do--and that means physical shape/size and look and ability).
The ones who complain about the program did not either put enough into their work ethic, or did not pay attention.
Just because you are in a program in NYC does NOT mean you will work on Broadway.
I'm sure the school has been through it's ups and downs since I worked there. But it sounds like--based on others comments--that you still have a great faculty and opportunity to make it work for you!
I do remember what an intense, nasty, overwhelming workout it was for most students. But I also remember that grin of satisfaction when the student's "got it!".
If you can't handle the program at AMDA, you are most likely not prepared for the real world of professional theater.
--just my ten cents...
"It's not so much do what you like, as it is that you like what you do." SS
"Time flies like an arrow, fruit flies like a banana." GMarx