Just got back from seeing this in St. Paul - it was such a tightly constructed play, and the actors were all wonderful.
Much like what was reported during the Broadway run, the audience was cheering when Captain Davenport came on stage at the beginning of Act 2, but rather than a shirtless Blair Underwood, it was Norm Lewis singing that got us going. He and Eugene Lee were just as charismatic as you'd expect, but I also want to give credit to the other actors, especially Tarik Lowe (who has never done a play before), Howard W. Overshown, Malik Esoj Child's, and Sheldon D. Brown.
There was a talkback with the cast afterwards, discussing their relationship to the material and talking about how regrettably relevant the themes of systemic hatred and racism were (something that hits home particularly hard in Minnesota). Just seeing these artists talk about their work was almost as engaging as the play itself.
Also for anyone who wants to see the show on Sunday instead of watching the Super Bowl, there's a discount code for $30 tickets available: SUNDAY30