I'm surprised there were any posts at all on this board between 8 pm and 11 pm. Apparently we were all at the Hilton theater tonight. No wonder it seemed so crowded. As I remarked to a friend at the theater, having seen Pirate Queen twice in Chicago I'm having a difficult time forming an opinion about the new improved version. I was very critical of PQ during its Chicago run. I thought the book and lyrics and direction were all abysmal.
Tonight I saw an entertaining, well crafted evening of theater with some great dancing, some strong performances, especially from Hadley Fraser, and a few pretty songs. It didn't change my life, but it sure beat watching "American Idol." The show has made incredible strides, especially in Act 1. The characters have motivations now, things happen for a reason, and I now care about what's going on. (Remember, I'm only talking about Act 1 here.) Once the Christening ended in Act 2 and the endless parade of ballads began with Tiernan's "Surrender" I felt that the show derailed. In fact my impression was that they just hadn't gotten around to fixing up the last 20 minutes yet.
The group of Long Island ladies sitting in front of me told that they loved the show, and someone else told me they thought it was better than Phantom. (I suppose that's damning with faint praise around here).
"I have got to have some professional music!" - Big Edie