I would also point out that Applegate is not exactly a big role. If not cast with a star, I would expect it to be assigned to the supporting actor category by the Tony Committee. Broderick had far more to do in Plaza Suite (which I did not see, so I cannot opine on the quality of his performance). As I remember, he sings just the one song, which is not vocally demanding."
The MB idea doesn't make sense to me - Mr. McClure was spectacular in the show."
I wouldn't say that Applegate is "not exactly a big role." I just saw the show over the weekend and Applegate is very active throughout even though, yes, he only has one song. Rob McClure was phenomenal - - I wasn't even a huge fan of his before seeing it, but left totally wowed by him. It would be a shame if they recast him with Broderick, who I haven't felt at all impressed by in recent years and who I doubt can deliver the range, energy, and oomph that Rob McClure gives. I think casting a new Lola would be a far more prudent move.