I recently saw this for a second time, and I am just sitting down to give my two cents. I loved it as much as I did the first time. I even loved the SB number as much as I remember loving it the first time, even though I was expecting it this time.
Having seen MHE on this trip, I would definitely vote for Jamie Lloyd, were I a Tony voter, even though I though that Michael Arden did an 'almost' great job. (I really have an issue with his making certain decisions without taking into consideration how they would impact viewing from the sides).
Much to my surprise, Scherzinger's voice was as strong as when I saw the show in October, something I really did not expect. Were I a Tony voter, I probably would have voted for her, although I might have been tempted to vote for Jasmine, who was so special in Boop. In fact, the four leads were all as good as I remembered, and David Thaxton absolutely should have been nominated, at the very least instead of Danny Burstein, who was adequate as Herbie IMO.
In another topic, I read that they are considering filming this. I would love to see a very meta version, in which some of the filming acknowledges the fact of an audience. I think the filming in the show itself could work with a meta approach.