Birdie Boy said: "None of them have a leg to stand on against Glenn Close. By the time I saw this new version, it all just seemed so small. Ben Brantley’s review was a straight up love letter, it reads like he was weeping tears of joy watching Glenn. He was a hell of a lot more enthused about Ms. Close’s performance in sunset than he ever was Bette Midler’s ham and cheese performance in Hello Dolly that same season. Glenn deserved the Tony that year, not Bette"
The Tony Awards won't allow nominations for people starring in the same role they've already won.
As for Ben Brantley - he did a tweet/review of this recent revival:
"Well I had a terrific time at "Sunset Blvd." - Jamie Lloyd's production distills a lumbering musical to the impure essence of noir: shadow, fog, betrayal, hunger. Scherzinger is raw narcissism trapped and magnified in a Vaelined lens: say what you will, it's a major performance."