Schmackary's Cookies

[Lunalaaaaaaaa]

Posted: 10/27/21 at 12:20pm

That's it. That's the thread.

You can also send cookies to your favorite Broadway shows because they are that awesome.

https://www.schmackarys.com/cookies-on-broadway/

[steven22]

Posted: 10/27/21 at 12:31pm

My wedding was in the Midwest and we had them packaged and shipped as favors. The customer service was wonderful!

[EDSOSLO858]

Posted: 10/27/21 at 12:40pm

One of the best cookie places in NYC!

[adotburr]

Posted: 10/27/21 at 12:40pm

I agree. Their customer service is great. I’ve ordered 6 times and 3 times we had issues with what was sent to us- one order was completely wrong, one order only half the cookies were sent (got the big cookies but they didn’t send the minis), another order the cookies weren’t sealed shut and were opened causing the cookies to be rock hard by the time they got to us. Each time they’ve resent my order without issue.

[Lunalaaaaaaaa]

Posted: 10/27/21 at 12:53pm

Jordan Levinson said: "One of the best cookie places in NYC!"

THIS always ^^^^

[Jordan Catalano]

Posted: 10/27/21 at 1:21pm

Now i need some maple bacon.

[TotallyEffed]

Posted: 10/27/21 at 1:25pm

Jordan Catalano said: "Now i need some maple bacon. "

That and the sort of funfetti one are the best!

[EDSOSLO858]

Posted: 10/27/21 at 1:27pm

TotallyEffed said: "Jordan Catalano said: "Now i need some maple bacon. "

That and the sort of funfetti one are the best!"

HEAVEN. I'm probably getting the Funfetti tomorrow before I see Doubtfire! The cookie is pink and white this month in honor of Breast Cancer Awareness Month. 

[Huss417]

Posted: 10/27/21 at 1:33pm

They might want to update their website. :)

"Please Note: All Broadway shows are currently closed. Any orders placed will be delivered once shows are back up and running."

[everythingtaboo]

Posted: 10/27/21 at 1:33pm

Breaking in to remind folks that Insomnia Cookies is coming to 53rd and 9th.

[LizzieCurry]

Posted: 10/27/21 at 1:35pm

I'm still salty (just like their cookies, ha) about how abruptly they halted their rewards system, but it's a fun place and community. I even still have a paper punch card from when they first opened. Even three years ago the staff marveled at it.

[Jordan Catalano]

Posted: 10/27/21 at 1:39pm

Whenever I’m there i always hope they’re sold out of maple bacon so i can try something else because if they have them, it’s physically impossible to not choose that.

[Huss417]

Posted: 10/27/21 at 1:47pm

Jordan Catalano said: "Whenever I’m there i always hope they’re sold out of maple bacon so i can try something else because if they have them, it’s physically impossible to not choose that."

They sound really good. Just went to the website and site says they are out of season.

[adotburr]

Posted: 10/27/21 at 1:47pm

I don’t eat pork bacon (personal choice). Assuming it’s pork bacon on the maple bacon cookies, are they THAT good that I need to break my no pork diet to try them?!

[Jordan Catalano]

Posted: 10/27/21 at 2:14pm

They are THAT good. And they just had them like a week ago.

[ColorTheHours048]

Posted: 10/27/21 at 2:17pm

The Ginger Rogers cookie is my favorite. But yeah, same Jordan. Any time they have Maple Bacon, it’s that AND, never instead.

[adotburr]

Posted: 10/27/21 at 2:42pm

Well… looks like I’m eating bacon !

[darquegk]

Posted: 10/27/21 at 7:17pm

Do NYC convenience stores still carry Soul Snacks brand cookies? I’ve had Schmackaray’s, but I did some writing with the singer of the Soul Snacks jingle and she sent my family some samples.

…I may have liked Soul Snacks better.

[sorano916]

Posted: 10/27/21 at 7:22pm

I'm sad that they closed their shop in NoHo. However, they never seemed busy there. 🙁

[Phantom4ever]

Posted: 10/27/21 at 10:24pm

I have enjoyed Schmackary's many times, but I don't often go there because the line is often too long and there a lot of line cutters, and the cookies are generally too hard. I wish they had a soft and gooey chocolate chip cookie. I feel like I have to eat any cookie I purchase from there almost immediately or it gets too hard to eat after just a few hours.  

[Bettyboy72]

Posted: 10/27/21 at 11:00pm

The funfetti is my fave but it literally gives me the
Biggest sugar buzz. I feel lit up like a Christmas tree for hours.

It’s a nice splurge before or after a show. The line moves fast and the staff are always friendly.

[Rainbowhigh23]

Posted: 10/27/21 at 11:10pm

I agree with the sugar high from Schmackarys cookies! I gained 20 pounds when I went there regularly in 2013 and lost it all recently until I went back when I saw Little Shop of Horrors last week and had a Funfetti.

[JSquared2]

Posted: 10/27/21 at 11:14pm

Rainbowhigh23 said: "I agree with the sugar high from Schmackarys cookies! I gained 20 pounds when I went there regularly in 2013 and lost it all recently until I went back when I saw Little Shop of Horrors last week and had a Funfetti. "

Just one funfetti?  Damn that must have been one big cookie! 

[Rainbowhigh23]

Posted: 10/27/21 at 11:27pm

It will be the first of many!!

[Lunalaaaaaaaa]

Posted: 10/31/21 at 11:54am

Schmackary's is a true 100/10. The line went out the door yesterday but there were no Oatmeal Scotchies or Red Velvets when we went

No line cutters (fortunately), just amazing Funfettis.