Well, under the category of "opinions are like..." I have to disagree with a few posters.
First, I think Michael Xavier put's his own stamp on Joe Gillis. I found his hard boiled cynicism a little more evident. He sounded great vocally; he's definitely a victim of the re-staging, especially "The Lady's Paying" and "This Time Next Year". He's not John Barrowman or Alan Campbell but he does sing the role very, very well. I also don't remember the second act opening "Sunset Boulevard" featuring Joe Gillis and his collection of abs. (whoosh!) MX does look nice.
Actually I was more disappointed with the orchestra buried onstage, the sound and orchestrations were not even. We were 4th row orchestra.
Yet again, Close does the crazy, "we had faces bit" a little too much. I still think her acting is why people like her, but for me Betty Buckley is still "my" true Norma Desmond. BB sings, acts, and wonderfully plays ND's strengths as well as fragility and tragic demise. Max's role which was much deeper in the original is reduced to his featured song. Siobhan Dillon is fine, both acting and singing as Betty Schaefer.
If this does continue without Close, they would really need a great quartet to keep this going. Alice Ripley still might seem too young for Norma, I don't think BB would do it indefinitely...the casting prod/dir would have their hands full re-casting.
Still, though very VERY costly, I'm glad we got to see it. Now, just like ALW, we've seen all 4 of his shows running at the same time.
I Can Has Cheezburger With This?