"The quality of the Spamalot score is very poor. It has 4 terriffic numbers (Bright Side of Life, The Song that Goes Like This, Knights of the Round Table, Won't Succeed on Broadway) but the rest of the songs are all forgettable.
DRS and Piazza have scores you can remember, songs you'll want to listent to again. Of the 16 songs from DRS, I like them all. They aren't all my favorites, but they are all terriffic songs. Same with Piazza, there isn't one I don't like. With Spamalot, out of 15 some of songs, I can only pick out 4 standouts."
Well okay, that's your opinion but in my opinion the Piazza music isn't as memorable. Are the singers good? Yes. And yes, it has some beautiful melodies, but truthfully (don't throw tomatoes at me for this) I find the Spamalot recording to just sound...great...everytime I listen! So what it won? I think a lot of people here are just angry because many believe Piazza is the better show of the two...whether or not that is your opinion, it is no tragedy that Piazza lost...it's still doing decent box office wise!
"We like to snark around here. Sometimes we actually talk about theater...but we try not to let that get in our way." - dramamama611