Kathy Bates definitely qualifies, madbrian (yes, it was late '80s, but still).
I think part of the reason I'm sounding so "vague" here is that the definition of a "star" has become more vague today. Just like "classic" or "legend."
Back in the golden age of both Hollywood and Broadway, there was a clear delineation (a "class system," if you will).
You were a star if the studio billed you above the title. That usually came with a "star" dressing room and a physical "star" on your dressing room door.
There was no question or gray area.
With Broadway, it was the same thing. Name above the title, star dressing room, and even a star on the door.
It's a different era now.
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22