Ok, so Rags is one of those flop OBCRs that plays so well and you think, "How did this only run 4 performances!?" Then you see a production.
I know I didn't see the Broadway version last night, but I've heard an audio and the same problems remain. The male characters are all extremely underwritten. Ben is super half-baked, Saul is a poor love interest for Rebecca (and he disappears for half of the show), and Nathan is an a$$hole who shows up at the end of act one out of the blue and is someone the audience instantly hates.
Nathan, in the hands of capable actor, should be like Father in Ragtime, but he isn't nearly as well-written and the actor last evening wasn't able to overcome the deficiencies in the script.
Rebecca is the only really well-developed character, and her songs are the best. I didn't like Children of the Wind being placed at the top of the show. It's a not a good beginning, and we don't care about Rebecca yet to really understand what she's singing about. I think it's more effective in its original slot.
The performance last night was...interesting. It's the best thing I've seen at The Beautiful Soup, but there were lots of hiccups. The light cues were a mess; Easy For You was performed in total darkness! The actors, god love them, just trucked on through the scene, but we couldn't see anything.
The orchestra sounded good, but they were way too loud, and often only the actress playing Rebecca could produce enough volume to be heard. The actress who played Rebecca also played the Holland Taylor role in Moose Murders. She has significantly improved since then, and she possesses a nice voice.
Reading many of the bios I realize that this production marked the New York acting debut of a good portion of the cast. To put it kindly, many of them were very green.
If Roundabout wants to revive this show the book needs to be heavily revived. I don't think it's possible, but this would be the PERFECT show for Encores to do.
Marie: Don't be in such a hurry about that pretty little chippy in Frisco.
Tony: Eh, she's a no chip!