Since there are so many threads about dream replacements, lets do one for every lead in the main shows currently playing.
Who are your dream replacements for:
Billy Elliot:
Billy-
Mrs. Wilkinson-
Dad-
Chicago:
Roxie-
Velma-
Billy-
In the Heights:
Usnavi-
Nina-
Jersey Boys:
Frankie-
La Cage:
Albin-
Georges-
Mamma Mia:
Sophie-
Donna-
Mary Poppins:
Mary Poppins-
Memphis:
Huey-
Felicia-
Promises,Promises:
Chuck-
Fran-
Rock of Ages:
Drew-
Sherry-
West Side Story:
Tony-
Maria-
Anita-
Phantom of the Opera:
Phantom-
Christine-
Wicked:
Glinda-
Elphaba-
Fiyero-
Wizard-
Next to Normal:
Diana-
Gabe-
Dan-
Natalie-
Hair:
Claude-
Berger-
Shelia-
Updated On: 6/27/10 at 01:04 PM
Swing Joined: 1/6/10
Andrea Burns as Diana in Next to Normal.
Broadway Legend Joined: 7/22/07
Mamma Mia:
Sophie- Bailey Hanks
West Side Story:
Anita- Nicole Scherzinger
Phantom of the Opera:
Christine- Erin Mackey
^ I second Erin for christine
GIVE THE TONYS BACK TO BROADWAY
Broadway Legend Joined: 11/9/04
Tonya Pinkins as Diana in N2N
Lisa Brescia as Elphaba in WICKED
Laura Benanti as Christine in PHANTOM
Anne Hathaway as Glinda in WICKED
Jessica Molaskey as Diana in N2N
Harvey Fierstein as Albin in LA CAGE AUX FOLLES
Promises, Promises
Fran: Megan Hilty!
La Cage:
Albin- Gary Beach
Memphis:
Huey- Adam Brazier
Felicia- Tamyra Gray
Promises,Promises:
Chuck- Hugh Jackman
Fran- Amy Spanger
I would like to see Mamma Mia replaced with another show.
Broadway Star Joined: 3/23/05
Muscle23ftl - yeh, I'd love to see Tamyra Gray play Felicia in Memphis, she would be amazing.
I'd love to see Harvey as Georges in LA CAGE.
I'd like to see Autumn Hurlbert as Nellie in South Pacific.
ROCK OF AGES
Drew: James Snyder
Sherrie: Julia Murney
Franz: Matt Doyle
Regina: Annaleigh Ashford
SOUTH PACIFIC
Nellie: Laura Benanti
Emile: Marc Kudisch
Lt. Cable: Stephen Pasquale
Bloody Mary: Pamela Isaacs
LA CAGE
Georges: Harvey Fierstein
Albin: David Hyde Pierce
Phoebe Strole as Natalie in Next To Normal. I'm sorry, I just can't let that one go...
Leah Hocking in Next to Normal
Phantom of the Opera
Christine- Patti Lupone
She probably shouldn't do it, but I still want Christina Aguilera to play Roxie. They could make it a big event, like when Usher came in.
Chorus Member Joined: 1/26/10
Rock of Ages
Drew - Yvan Pedneault
Sherrie - Elicia Mackenzie
^ Toronto leads.
LOL Obihave!
Billy Elliot:
Billy: Jutin Bieber
Dad: Jm J Bullock
Chicago:
Roxie-Judi Dench
Velma-Maggie Smith
La Cage:
Albin-Russel Crowe
Georges-Harrison Ford
Mamma Mia: close, please
Mary Poppins: close, please
Memphis: close, please
Promises,Promises:
Fran- someone more youthful than Chenowith, maybe Shirley MacLaine
Phantom of the Opera:
Phantom-George Wendt
Christine-Rhea Perlman
Wicked:
Glinda-Nikki Blonski
Elphaba-Mayim Bailek
Next to Normal:
Diana-Jackie Hoffman
Hair:
Claude-Michael Cerveris
Billy Elliot:
Mrs. Wilkinson-cat zeta-jones
Mary Poppins:
Mary Poppins- sutton foster
Memphis:
Felicia- heather h (aida)
Promises,Promises:
Fran-kerry butler
Rock of Ages:
Sherry-megan hilty/elizabeth stanley
drew-ace young
Next to Normal:
Diana- suitton foster
Gabe-
Dan-greg jabara
Natalie-krysta rodrigrez
Swing Joined: 7/2/10
Chicago:
Roxie - Ruthie Henshall
Velma - Bebe Neuwirth ( sorry but i just love her Velma )
Mary Poppins:
Mary Poppins - Sutton Foster
Promises,Promises:
Fran- Megan Hilty
Rock of Ages:
Sherry- Megan Hilty
Phantom of the Opera:
Christine- Erin !
Wicked:
Elphaba- Rachel Tucker !!! ( Broadway next PLEASE!)
Next to Normal:
Diana- Bernadette Peters
Hair: All of the Revival cast are perfect!
Videos