It's all over: IDOL packs it up for another year.

I think Jasmine or Diana are in trouble also. I think they're both good (Diana more than Jasmine but Diana's young and needs to develop her stage personality more) but the two talentless guys seem safe because voters are stupid and those two girls aren't as strong as the others.

i hope its big red. he should have gone 2 weeks ago.

I agree red won't go-it's too easy to find a movie tune to suit his voice. How bout "Moon River", red?

---

oh god, PLEASE send John Stevens home!!!! it's time!!

On the Idol site, there are 4 or 5 different people who claimed they were at the taping, and the yall gave out different song lists. One person said JPL sang "Man of Constant Sorrow" from O, Brother, and blew everyone away!! Someone else said Diana sang "Tomorrow" from Annie, and she was raked over the coles for it. I guess we'll find out tonight!!!

I love John Stevens!!

I stick with my earlier prediction: either Diana DeGarmo or Jasmine Trias are going to bite the big one.

I also predict that George Huff and Puff will be in the bottom three. (This will make him an official bottom.) But thank you so much for not bouncing, George. No one likes a bouncing bottom. On second thought....

---

they all were amazing tonight..

i think the winner should be fantasia. amazing.

i think john peter lewis, john stevens, and george should be in the bottom three with one of the johns going.

Go get 'im and that cheese puff on his head, Princess!!

---

Tonight's performances were very good. Of course Big Red and JPL were as annoying as anything, but the rest was really good. Diana did a very good job on that song from Titanic (I'm so bad with titles!), and I thought that La Toya was amazing. There was something about Fantasia that bugged me, but even still, she was incredible. Jasmine was also very good, and so was Jennifer. George Huff, even though very good, annoyed me a bit. Oh- you know who else was really annoying? Quintin(sp?).

I really hope Diana or Jasmine don't got tomorrow. I hope it's one of the Johns, because they're just annoying.

---

It's Quentin. Awesome director and I thought he was mostly spot on--especially in his critique of Diana. Yeah, he was there to plug his film, but at least he was a celebrity judge who was able to make criticisms instead of just kissing ass through plastic surgery smiles.

1. Fantasia -- stunning and solidifies (if there was ever a doubt) that this girl will be a superstar
2. Latoya --gorgeous
3. Jennifer Hudson --I wanted more fire from her, but she's kicking ass
4. Jasmine
5. (tie) George Huff --bland
5. (tie) Diana --bland
5. (tie) JPL --best performance of his (and ain't he hot without his shirt!!!!)
8. Jon --on my last nerve

I predict Diana's going home. She was in the bottom 3, and I think the Titanic will sink her.

---

Updated On: 4/15/04 at 02:11 AM

(joey, don't say it, DON'T SAY IT!!!)

JPL i can't I can NOT he is a grabage pail kid to me and I can NOT take him. I think he is HORRIBLE! I think John Stevens is way better and he is not even up there for me. Sure best performance from Up Chuck but that is not saying much he is just not good.