CT2NYC said: "I'm the person who suggested Billy Eichner because he's funny, he has a strong connection to NYC and NYC actors, he loves Broadway, and he can sing. Plus, people who don't watch the Tonys would watch them for him. People seem to forget that CBS doesn't air the Tonys as a public service. They and their advertisers would like people to watch them, and, for that reason, some of the suggestions on this thread are pretty ridiculous. I LOVE the Tonys, but their viewership is notoriously low. Having a host that is known outside of the Broadway community is a way to make them more accessible to the general public.
The key for the host is to draw in viewers who aren't Broadway addicts and aren't people who would tune in regardless of who is hosting. I think you vastly overestimate the number of people who wouldn't watch normally but will tune in because of him. People want to see a major star, not a minor, basic cable "celebrity" and I have doubts his core audience of people who enjoy adlib sidewalk gags are all of a sudden going to want to know all about theater. Suffice to say, if you want to make sure CBS walks away from this once and for all, he'd be perfect.