VintageSnarker said: "EllieRose2 said: "It took place in the 1970s and filmed in 1999. You can't really look at it through a 2022 lens, it doesn't make sense."
But it's a story they're choosing to put on stage in 2022. If Tootsie, Dear Evan Hansen, Jagged Little Pill, etc. can be critiqued, why not Almost Famous? Hell, even Funny Girl was critiqued and that was a revival (with an updated book). There's a load of stuff... the unconscious kiss, the nonsense that comes out of Penny's and Sapphire's mouths, William's general worldview... Theater happens in the present. You can't perform that stuff night after night uncritically the way you can make allowances for a movie that was filmed years ago and (for the most part) can't be edited.
I certainly think there's a way of telling this story but not as an uncritical, feel-good musical and perfect reproduction of the film."
I agree. I think even those of us who are huge fans of the movie ought to be able to see that. My personal philosophy is that if you grew up with something, you're grandfathered in -- in the sense that you can love it in your mind, in your private life, and excuse whatever flaws you want to. But for instance, if I watch the movie with my daughters when they're old enough, I will point out the problems. Same goes, as you said, for "putting it back out there" in terms of a 2022 musical production.