Patrick wasn't th most animated of people in day to day life though, he was perfectly ordinary, Bale played it th same way. It's when he's coming undone that he comes alive.....and hates it. He's bored of everything around him, it would seem silly if he was really animated, that's just not him.
Its come up a few times and I find it an interesting talking point. People saying it's hard to do a musical when the lead character is so unsympathetic, why is that? We can happily watch it on film or tv so why not the stage? In AP case the emotion is there it's just not an emotion that will have you uplifted and moved, it's disgust, boredom and self obsession, is it not refreshing to have a musical that allows something different?
As for the cramming it with style to fall back on I simply can't agree. The style is what the book and film are about, expense, looking great, the best clothes, the best technology etc, that is a character in the show itself, it's about excess.
Do people think the age of the audience will play in to response? This show seems like it's aimed at people in their late teens to 40s, I can't help thinking older audiences and theatre purists will hate this show, which I get, but what does that do for long term prospects of the show?
Namo i love u but we get it already....you don't like Madonna