Posted: 3/27/17 at 11:38pm
I was there tonight, and despite some lovely costumes and a nice performance from Mary Beth Peil, I thought Anastasia was a swing and a miss. The whole thing felt so bland and the plot (what little there was) just kept plodding along. The production, especially in act one, never felt like it could accelerate past first gear. I don't thing anything genuinely sparked until Caroline O'Connor came on the scene in act two- she takes over the show for about 20 minutes in a rather extraneous, yet crowd-pleasing and invigorating subplot.
I wasn't expecting so much of the humor to be as cornball as it was (e.g. You better save the first dance for me!/I've given up dancing...for lent.- I mean groan.)
I think a big part of the reason I found it so unengaging was that you're always 10-15 minutes ahead of where the characters are. As soon as a scene or a song starts you can tell exactly where it's going. Dmitry and Vlad has a Higgins/Pickering song where they Rain in Spain Anya into being Anastasia. Of course she struggles at first, but by the end of the song, by George, I think she's got it! The show offers few surprises, which is why O'Connor is so entertaining because for the first time all evening you're not quite sure what someone is going to do.
Gleb's subplot held little interest, and honestly the whole character could be cut and it wouldn't affect the story at all. Maybe Gleb/Dmitry/Anya were once supposed to be a love triangle? Or a partially unrequited love triangle? If that's the case, I found it unsuccessful.
Act one mainly focuses on the trio of Anya/Dmitry/Vlad, but once they get to Paris for act two the focus fractures as we're sent on detours with the supporting players.
The projections were sometimes fine, but other times they became uber cheesy; at all times I was very aware of them and I think they pulled focus from the action on stage.
Maybe most disappointing for me was the score; I adore Ragtime- it's truly one of my favorites- but this felt pedestrian- with the only two standout melodies being Once Upon a December and Journey to the Past.
There seemed to be plenty of teens there enjoying themselves, so maybe the show is hitting the mark with its core demographic, but unless they cut the act two opener and replace it with Ah, Paris! for Mary Beth Peil to sing again, I probably won't be going back.