BWay Shows That Did Not Get a Cast Recording — Page 2

Add me to the chorus of American Psycho. The Broadway cast sang that score 20x better than what is preserved. Ben Walker crushed that score. It's still amazes me that he did not receive a Tony nod for his Bateman. He was fully committed on every level and firing on all cylinders. I saw the show four times including closing night. It was stunning.

I know this will be a controversial ask, but I would have loved The Roundabout production of Pal Joey to be preserved. I thought the cast was exceptional, including Risch, who so many maligned. I thought Stockard's song styling was emotional and effective. Martha Plimpton was a revelation. I saw that show 3 times.

---

"Platinum" with Alexis Smith and Lisa Mordente. There was a live soundboard recording floating around that I was sent but as far as I know there was no studio recording. I saw it twice in Philadelphia before it went to New York. (It made a short stop there at the, then, Shubert Theater).

---

I took my kids to see one of the final performances of THE ADVENTURES OF TOM SAWYER which I don't think has a commercially available cast recording (though I believe the cast did make a recording).We loved that show.

I also wish that the Broadway revival of PETER PAN with Sandy Duncan was recorded. The new orchestrations and vocal arrangements (not to mention Duncan's fantastic performance) should have been preserved.

Updated On: 3/3/21 at 07:50 PM

To be completly honest, I would love a professional "cast recording" of "An Evening with Patti LuPone and Mandy Patinkin". I loved this simple, jewel-box of a show. It was so beautiful.

The most Jekyll & Hyde revival starring Constantine Maroulis and Deborah Cox had a studio album released, but no official cast recording. I loved the vocals and orchestrations in the production, so I am bummed there is no cast album.

---

Yeah I hear you. It's definitely still the standard for revivals to get cast recordings these days. But I feel like, if we're naming examples of productions that didn't get CRs, the revivals are generally less noteworthy examples than the originals.

West Side Story is a strange one because most of the score changes are by subtraction. Will anyone buy a cast recording of West Side Story that's mostly the same as usual, except that it's missing "I Feel Pretty" and the "Somewhere" ballet? Because otherwise, the score is done pretty traditionally - surprisingly so, considering the production is so avante garde. Even the orchestrations in this revival sound pretty traditional.

I would've loved a cast recording of Into the Woods at the Delacorte. Not only because the cast was so great, but also because of the way they re-imagined the end of Last Midnight, from an arrangement standpoint, and I LOVE what they did with it!

La Strada, 1969! Thankfully a scratchy but listenable audience recording captures yet another one of Bernadette's amazing performances. I suspect if a high quality studio recording was available theatre fans would still be listening to the opening 'Seagull, Starfish, Pebble', 'Belonging', a fun 'You're Musical' number with Larry Kert and Larry Kert's 'Sooner or Later' today.

---

Such a shame that the original Broadway cast of Carrie the Musical did not get to record their performance.
The first revival of Sweeney Todd was not recorded either In 1989.
The off—Broadway Revival of Sweeney did not get a recording too.
This one has been said several times already but I'm amazed and somehow bemused that the original Broadway production of Phantom with Judy Kaye no less was never recorded too.

Joshua Rosenthal said: "Marilyn: An American Fable
2004 Revival of La Cage Aux Folles
King Kong
"

I have to agree about KING KONG. While some of the lyrics were cringe-worthy, the orchestral passages were really impressive.

---

i will never not complain about Shuffle Along specifically because of how obsessed i was with Adrienne Warren’s performance of I’m Craving for That Kind of Love

i would have also loved a recording of the recent revival of Cabaret though would have preferred Emma Stone

also still upset the Kristin Chenoweth revival of The Apple Tree wasn’t recorded. one of my favorite voices singing one of my favorite scores and it didn’t happen

Something More! was one of the few musicals starring Barbara Cook that wasn’t recorded

Chita Rivera: The Dancer’s Life, The Times They Are a-Changin, Good Vibrations, Rain, Holler If Ya Hear Me, After Midnight, The Look of Love, Urban Cowboy, Never Gonna Dance, One Mo Time are some non-revivals from this century that weren’t recorded (pretty sure most are jukeboxes though).

---

JBroadway said: "theatreguy12 said: "
I remember when the show opened it got largely mixed, at best, reviews. And I know “at best” is being generous.
I also remember though those on the board here largely liking it. Myself included. I’m glad we at least have the London recording,even though itwas a little different. I found it an extremely provocative musical.
And having the window card displayed along with numerous other Broadway show cards here in my home, it is always the one that pulls the focus and becomes the topic of discussionwith friends wanting to know what it was like. A definite conversation piece."





IMHO, American Psycho was just a few years ahead of its time."

I would agree with you on this.

Speaking of, I actually bought a teeshirt for the musical when I saw it in NY but can't find the damn thing. Went on eBay, just out of some curiosity, and lo and behold someone in PA was selling one, and it was in my size.

There were like 3 or 4 people "watching" it though, of all things, and I ended up not winning it.

Interesting that such a small show that had such a short shelf life on Broadway, would still be turning up souvenirs, and would have enough of a demand to turn such a simple sale of an item like that into a showdown. Bummed.

Elfuhbuh said: "I would’ve liked to have a cast recording for the recent Broadway revival of Jesus Christ Superstar. I enjoyed that cast a lot."

I'd like to have a full cast recording for the original Broadway production. Apparently they did record the whole thing, but Decca/MCA decided with the concept album such a hot seller, there was no need to have two complete versions (sure changed their minds when it came to the movie). I think the tapes have subsequently been lost.

"The Best Little Whorehouse Goes Public" was recorded and released.



"Shelter" was recorded by Columbia/CBS but not released.



More of a crime than the single-disc Broadway "Superstar": The single-disc world-premiere original 1978 London cast recording of "Evita." As was the case with the NY "Superstar," there had already been a strong-selling double-LP studio album. What did get preserved on that '78 London "Evita" cast recording (made prior to longer-length CDs) is thrilling, so it's a crime that Elaine Paige's complete performance was not recorded and numerous exciting passages are missing. (The Broadway '79 "Evita" did of course get two discs.)



As fate would have it, Elena Roger got to record her Eva twice, a single disc in London then a double-disc set for Broadway.

Updated On: 3/10/21 at 09:16 PM