Bill Snibson said: "A-list celebrities don't and are advised not to do new musicals. I could see him doing a 16 weekplay. It would sell phenomenally and be an "event" for sure. Amusical revival might be a stretch since that typically requires a year commitment."
I would say above all it's a matter of practicality:
- musicals happen on unique schedules and can take years to develop (workshops, out of towns, etc)
- as a result of the above, a big new musical will generally cost more than a big revival. The current Sweeney can be capitalized for $13 million; a new musical starring Groban & Ashford with a similar design & personnel would be quite a lot more.
- With a new work you don't quite know what you're getting yourself into. With a revival, you at least know that the script & score won't change.
- Ryan Gosling in a new musical becomes "The Ryan Gosling Show" and it becomes impossible to replace with an equivalent star after he leaves (somewhere between 4-12 months) and usually the box office tanks.
- There's also, of course, the matter of stamina when doing a musical for a sustained run.
Would love to see him try his hand at a play (ideally a new play!) or a benefit concert of a musical sometime.
Updated On: 3/11/24 at 03:54 PM