I was in a good college production way back in 1962 as Harry McAfee(I played it as Paul Lynde did) and the thing that stands out to me is how truly funny the script is--our large cast was in stitches all through the 6 week rehearsal period. It is imortant to cast a great Mae Peterson--she has such wonderful sarcastic lines. I hope Bill Irwin will make a good Harry McAfee. I think it needs to remain a period piece, with as little updating as possible. Maybe the TV show could be switched to American Idol. But then what about the lyrics to "Ed Sullivan"?, a very funny number. On second thought, skip the American Idol idea.
How about Cheyenne Jackson as Conrad Birdie?
I would love to see BYE,BYE, BIRDIE revived in a good full scale production, with the two added numbers: the title song, from the movie, and "Take a Giant Step", written for the Tommy Tune touring production. How about it, Roundabout?
"Madam Rose...and her daughter...Gypsy!"