"Also, as someone who lost someone in 9/11, I have a bit of a problem with anything that involves it being musicalized. It's just very distasteful to me."
"The show may not take place in New York as it is happening, but the show is most certainly about 9/11. The lyrics like "Someone used the thing I loved most as the bomb" or something is absolutely cringey and distasteful."
I imagine many people on this board lost loved ones on 9/11. I certainly did. You have every right to your feelings, but understand not everyone feels the same way. Also, icecreambenjamin, you haven't seen the show, correct? How, then, can you say that "The show is about people coming together during a time of crisis and all that, but the show is still about 9/11" with such certainty? The show is NOT ABOUT 9/11. If you'd seen it, you would understand that.I'm not suggesting you should see it, given your objections to the material, but you can't really have an opinion on a show you haven't seen, based merely on the music.
The lyric you [mis]quoted " 'Flight 846, there's been a terrorist action', and the thing that I loved more than anything in the world was used as the bomb" is a nearly direct quote from Captain Beverly Bass, one of the pilots who had to land her plane in Gander that day. It is the first time she drops her professional mask and truly expresses emotion. It's a powerful moment and my bet is that it will garner Jen Colella a Tony nomination.
I guess that my point is that most of the people in this show are real people (or composites in a couple cases). The show is their stories, 9/11 is the reason they came together, but it isn't really even a backdrop for the show. Again, I'm not trying to change your mind about seeing it, but I will say that you're not seeing it for the wrong reasons.