What’s interesting about this is that Christopher Ashley has directed two feature films before, though neither of them were critically-acclaimed. In 1995, he made a film adaptation of Paul Rudnick’s play Jeffrey (not about me, obviously), which he also originally directed on stage. But overall, the film itself received mixed-to-positive reviews from critics. It wasn’t until a few years ago when he finally made a follow-up film which was an adaptation of Lynn Ahrens & Stephen Flaherty’s debut musical, Lucky Stiff, which received very mixed-to-negative reviews (though I must say, while the film wasn’t great, I still certainly got a kick out of it).
Not only that, but the overall track record for stage directors repeating their directorial duties on film adaptations of their musicals hasn’t been great. While there has been some exceptions to the rule such as…
George Abbott (with Stanley Donen)-The Pajama Game & Damn Yankees
Joshua Logan-South Pacific
Jerome Robbins (with Robert Wise)-West Side Story
Morton DaCosta-The Music Man
Jim Sharman-The Rocky Horror Picture Show
There’s also been…
Gene Saks-Mame
Harold Prince-A Little Night Music
Susan Stroman-The Producers
Phyllida Lloyd-Mamma Mia!
Though there is an interesting case for the film adaptation of 1776 (which was directed by Peter Hunt, who won a Tony for directing the original Broadway production) where while it hasn’t really been seen as an all-time classic, it still has such a devoted cult following.