BwayLB said: "Miles2Go2 said: "^^^ I was hoping for more than “isn’thalf bad.” Lol"
All I can say to you left is at the end the audience was on their feet."
People stand up for everything these days, though...not being snarky, it's just the way it is. I stood up too, only because I felt badly not doing it when everyone else was (I'm not the obnoxious type to sit there in silent protest), so I'm not sure that's necessarily indicative of how great the show was.
At least where I live, it seemed clear that most of the audience had never actually seen a performance of Rent, so for them, I'm sure it was fabulous - which is great. For me, though, it holds too special a place in my heart among musicals for a number of personal reasons, so maybe I'm more picky (I'm also admittedly more picky than the average audience member here because I'm a theater geek). And, while I missed the entire OBC by a month, I saw it on Broadway with Anthony Rapp and a phenomenal replacement cast including Norbert Leo Butz as Roger and Wilson Cruz as Angel, and I also saw the first two national tours so those are tough shoes to fill. I wouldn't have gotten tickets but for my daughter, and really hoped I would enjoy it, but I just didn't. It made me sad, and not in the right way.
For what it's worth, I read reviews afterwards (didn't want to go in with preconceived notions of whether or not I'd like it). They tended to align with my thoughts. I think the cast is working really hard and putting their hearts into it, but they just aren't ready to take on a show like Rent - at least not for those of us who know what a really great performance of the show can evoke. I think one critic (forget the city) used the title "All Guts, No Glory". Aside from the clever play on "One Song, Glory", I thought that nailed it.
I will say, the new Angel was superb (I read that the first one was great also), and I'll be watching for his name in the future. With some work on his stamina he could be a force someday. And the guy who plays Tom Collins has a really beautiful, unique singing tone and had some nice acting moments where he did disappear into the character, at least briefly. But as a whole, it just never came together.