I just saw the show tonight. Dee was probably the worst Elphaba I've seen. Her No Good Deed was actually pretty good, but my jaw dropped at how painful her The Wizard and I was.
Erin was a wonderful Galinda, I thought!!
For a good portion of the show, I was thinking about Diana being Elphaba. I'm sure it's been made clear that I LOVE Diana, but I'm not sure she is right for the part of Elphaba. I was actually hoping to lose at the Wicked lottery tonight so I could see Toxic Avenger... but alas, I won Wicked. Has Diana grown a lot? I'm just not sure her voice is right for the part of Elphaba right now.
...but if she were cast as Elphaba, you'd better believe I would be there on her opening night!!
"If it walks like a Parks, if it wobbles like a Parks, then it's definitely fat and nobody loves it." --MA