Posted: 8/14/24 at 10:20pm
ErmengardeStopSniveling said: "I think there IS a way for these live-action remakes to be done artfully by the right people, this just ain't it.
There has to be a level of reimagining.
I just scrubbed through Disney+ and the original Disney movie is 83 minutes soaking wet. The woodsman tries to kill her at minute 8, she arrives at the Dwarves' house at minute 15. About half the songsare novelty numbers for the dwarfs. The leading character demonstrates a mental capacity of an eleven year old. Walt improved his formula on Cinderella and Sleeping Beauty.
There's a lot of room to expand!"
I mean I won't disagree but that discounts what is still so striking about it. A lot of the cinematography--and certainly all the genuinely terrifying stuff with the Queen/Witch (and the chase in the woods) holds up so well next to ANY live action film of its time, if not better (this is true of all of the initial "great five" Disney features, when Walt was the most invested and was throwing time and money at the works with the hope of attracting the largest audience possible, and not just families--Snow White, Pinocchio, Fantasia, Dumbo, even if that was done on a budget to try to recoup the huge losses from the films after Snow White, and Bambi. Just stunning example of film work.)
And the way that music is used--I realized the last time I watched it that it really in many ways is a full on operetta (complete with a lot of rhymed dialogue)--I'm not sure how Pasek and Paul will be able to fit in with this style--and of course Disney doesn't get credit for making sure the songs are relatively well integrated into the plot when that wasn't yet the musical standard.