The reason for the hype in this case is actually well-founded, considering I'd wager the city is not well-prepared for a hurricane hit, and current tracks are indicating a landfall near or over NYC is possible- something that has not happened for 50 years. A category 2 or even a category 1 could be extremely disruptive to the NYC area, not only causing power outages but making commutes impossible.
That being said, hurricanes tracks are notoriously hard to pin down. They will often do their own thing, so it's just as possible the storm will miss us.
"...everyone finally shut up, and the audience could enjoy the beginning of the Anatevka Pogram in peace."