I loved the repeated shot of Cinderella at her mother's grave with "I wish."
It works so well for me because they flash back to that moment, and it makes me think ( as the audience), knowing what we know about how things worked out, if she could go back to that moment in time, would she do it all again and wish for it?
That's something you can't do in a stage production with such limited time. I loved that touch in the film.
I saw it again today, and I think I actually liked it more the second time. This is easily my favorite film adaptation of a musical since Chicago.
Dreamgirls was great, but gutted a little too much of the score for me, and Hairspray was great with the one misfire of Travolta playing Edna "legit" rather than a more campy Harvey/Divine spin. It took a lot of edge out of the overall tone. Both are damn good, though.
While Chicago departed greatly from the stage version, it was improved, IMO.
Into the Woods is wonderfully faithful to the stage production even with its trims and tucks. And the cast is so uniformly excellent. I really reveled in each of their performances again today.
So ... go, Rob Marshall and do what ever you want to do next. Yeah, Nine was a bit of a misfire (with some shining moments), but you have delivered my two favorite movie musical adaptations of the past 15 years.
*bows respectfully*
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22