SmokeyLady said: "DanS3 said: "Papi2013 said: "So something interesting that I heard last night from Bryan The Business Analyst ( a theater business analyst on the Tok). I have not fact checked any of this. Apparently when Audra won her Tony for Porgy and Bess the production and her performance where not exactly well received. The production took many liberties and was in fact retitled Gershwins Porgy and Bess. Sondheim wrote a editorial for the times blasting the production. Apparently the theater community got very defensive then about Audra and according to what he said last night, the sentiment won her the not deserved Tony. Will history repeat itself?"
The Tony would be completely deserved if she were to win this year. I know her voice is divisive in this role, but, there's no denying that her acting is top form and she is the best of the bunch in this category. But, Nicole is going to win. She was phenomenal as well, but, I didn't feel like she was actually "acting". She was voguing, posing, glamming it up, and singing her ass off...but...it wasn't really acting. Just my opinion."
I appreciate your opinion. But you nailed exactly what my main issue was with Audras performance. She was acting. I did not believe one word out of her. It was a glossy yet empty performance. Just in my opinion. But I do enjoy her."
I don't think he was saying Audra didn't deserve to win for Bess, he was saying it was a nailbiter between Jan Maxwell and Aurda, similar to how its seemingly a nail biter between Nicole and Audra this year...and it was potentially that controversy in the final days that pushed her over the top.