binau said: "TimeToDither said: "kidmanboy said: "I have a feeling some perceptions of the score will change once there is a cast recording. It is very well written."
A cast album justifies it being boring in the actual musical?"
No I think the point is that it's hard to take in a new score for the first time - so the patterns, melodies, harmonies etc. aren't as striking or obvious until you listen a couple times. But sometimes once you're familiar it all kind of clicks into place.
That said, I'm still not 100% convinced in the Maybe Happy Ending score so I'll wait for myself (and I have been listening to the demo tracks!). That's not to say there is anything 'wrong' with it, it serves it purpose. I just think for me at least based on the one viewing the real strength of the show was the book (characters + twists + emotions), the acting and the production/staging.
In a weird way, I kind of thought the experience was more like a play with music than a musical with a capital B for Broadway. Even looking at the website now I can't say that it reflects the tone of what I thought I saw - which I remembered to be a bit more subtle and not big bright colours like a dance show such as "Here Lies Love".
This photo below is more how I remembered it...

I meant to respond to this earlier but I’m glad I waited now that I have listened to the cast recording a couple of times. There are some excellent points here. Maybe Happy Ending is not your classic play-with-music, as the show is filled with songs (both by the two leads and the crooner) as well as instrumental music that is critical in setting the mood for various scenes. The cast recording reminded me of that, as did my response in the theater that the score was ideal for the show.
Plus, I am definitely a lyrics person and the score is so well-crafted, especially given the challenge of writing what is basically a two-person show. Darren Criss and Helen J. Shen, in different ways given their robot characters’ differences, both have tricky acting challenges to get the audience invested in their characters and their relationship - and the darker themes that drive the story.
This is, in the end, a musical damned with faint praise for being ‘cute’ that’s about how we deal with abandonment, loss, isolation and death. All the rom-com tropes and colorful set design can’t hide that. And that’s why the musical works so well.
The ending is effective because it manages to leave us with a tangle of emotions that felt earned to me.