Whatever caused Lauren Ambrose to miss four or five consecutive shows, it wasn't in evidence during her return performance at the Wednesday matinee. This was my second visit, with the first coming midway through the previews, front row center. This time is was center left, row K. I came to this production originally knowing not a thing about Lauren Ambrose, but I like her performance. I can't think of many areas in which her performance could have been improved. Certainly I'll always miss Julie Andrews' intense but grand fun "Show Me," but there are not many Julie Andrews around.
It is easy to overlook Harry Hadden-Paton, because he slides so easily into the role of Higgins. I don't think of comparing him to Rex. Harry is Higgins to me.
The Wednesday matinee audience was a little slow warming up to the show. Even the first climax of "Rain in Spain" and "Danced all Night" didn't bring the house down. Are Wednesday matinees known for older and more sluggish audiences?
It was actually Ascot that I think turned the matinee audience. That scene should win a lifetime achievement Tony for all who participated in staging it. The set, the costumes, The slow, refined movement of the company and the droll description of the races. And the introduction of Eliza with her very limited Ascot-suitable vocabulary. Dame Diana may be luxury casting, but her presence has its effect when made.
There was one element in the production today that puzzled me. I'm not sure if it was in the preview I saw, or even if I imagined what I heard. At the end of the first Act, when they were all leaving to go to the ball, Higgins was the last one to leave the house. One of the comments that he made revealed for the first time his affection for Eliza. I wish I could remember the details. It was, for example, calling out to them that he would be right out, because he was anxious to see Eliza again, but the end of the statement just tailed off so that he was just addressing himself, "I want to - then to himself with feeling - see Eliza again." But it wasn't that exactly.
It was so surprising to see that scene because Higgins did not pick up on it at all in the second act through "You Did It" to the confrontation with Eliza at his mother's house. Higgins, I do believe, did not again admit to having strong feelings for Eliza until "I've Grown Accustomed To Her Face."
It's hard for me to take Higgins as a bad man. When he is singing his "A Hymn to Him" I suddenly thought that I was listening to John Cleese in the BBC comedy Fawlty Towers, endlessly blustering away at his persecution at the hands of his wife and all others, but no one is listening.
So will Eliza's determined departure from Wimpole Street be the end of Eliza and Higgins? Not likely. Neither of them has anywhere else to go. Eliza is too far above Freddy for marriage. And the new Eliza's sole friends, and very good friends, are Pickering and Mrs. Higgins.
But why obsess over this. I guess it must be fun. But, let's let Dame Diana have the last word (and she has played Eliza in Pygmalion):
That final scene proves that Henry and Eliza have a high regard for each other even though a full relationship is not possible. What happens next is not for me to say. Each member of the audience will have his or her own interpretation of where that relationship is going. That’s the wonderful part about it.