For the die-hard conservative (thinks the lion king is too modern): King and I. It's long (so worth the money?!) and these sorts of audience members fawn over R&H.
For the adventurer (age won't stop them from seeing what is new and hip!): Something Rotten. Especially if they're familiar with musicals in general, it's a lot of fun and has some great production numbers.
For the classy (doesn't mind something new, but prefers to keep things sophisticated): An American In Paris. Gershwin + Ballet + Great modern sets/designs + Palace Theatre. Can't really go wrong.
For the super religious: Amazing Grace. Not great reviews, sure, but I found that it resonated with an older audience. Sure, it has its issues, but it is FAR from the worst show to be on broadway. You'll be able to get a great price, great locations, and Chuck Cooper is AMAZING in it. In addition, it has some very neat effects, decent sets/costumes, and the music is enjoyable. Again, not the greatest show you'll ever see, but if you have some church-goers, it'll be a home run. (Warning: closes 10/25)
Other safe bets: Wicked, Gentleman's Guide, Beautiful, Matilda, Phantom
Updated On: 9/28/15 at 12:44 PM