I had no problem with the play being a why-done-it instead honoring the tropes of a traditional mystery (or even a Law and Order episode). Our access to the narrative is our emotional -- and now historical -- investment in the protagonist's prism on her nearly destroyed life, personal and professional. We are curious to hear how she survived the unspeakable, and what her heroic survival says about overcoming the oppressive world built by the play -- 1949 academia, in the Midwest in particular -- and America in any era. I was hanging on the character's perceptions, her "experience of her experience," not plot revelations. As the author intended. I think it works quite effectively.
I had a strong negative response to the set, a kind of whimsical use of floating, off-center bookcases that felt more suitable to a semi-comical surreal style. The play has little humor, certainly nothing that occurs can be easily distanced with wry commentary. So the multiple flying bookcases, rather than enhance the verisimilitude or the thematic content, distracted in the worse sense. We are trained on the woman telling this harrowing story, yet our eyes unavoidably work hard to tune out a twee dreamscape of library imagery that makes our full immersion more difficult. It's a major misfire, the wrong elements stylized. .
"I'm a comedian, but in my spare time, things bother me." Garry Shandling