I’d love to see Urinetown come back to Broadway more than any other show to come out since the 90s. While I’m not entirely certain of who should be who, I’ve had a couple ideas. Andrew Rannells/Ethan Slater as Bobby Strong, Annaleigh Ashford/Ashley Park as Hope Cladwell, Patrick Page/Bertie Carvel as Caldwell B. Cladwell, Rachel Bay Jones/Jennifer Laura Thompson (wouldn’t it be great if she could get two tony nominations out of this show for different characters?) as Penelope Pennywise, Sarah Stiles as Little Sally, and Jeff McCarthy reprising his role as Officer Lockstock (my alternate would be Patrick Page, but I really can’t see anyone being as unbelievably hilarious in this part as McCarthy)
Edit: I’ll throw Michael Cerveris in there as another Cladwell. Based on age, Page and Cerveris are more suited to the part than Carvel, although I think all would bring the right kind of wicked yet funny energy to the role
I’ve also recently posted about a dream cast for The Producers that I believe could be wonderful. Norbert Leo Butz and Ethan Slater would star as Max Bialystock and Leo Bloom, with a supporting cast being rounded out by Bertie Carvel as Roger DeBris, Christian Borle as Carmen Ghia, Taylor Louderman as Ulla, and Danny Burstein as Franz Liebkind.
Updated On: 7/5/19 at 11:27 PM