Posted: 12/11/25 at 12:03am
I finally got to see this tonight and it is truly just a goddamn delight of a production. A perfectly cast, well-directed production of an utterly charming show. I haven’t seen a production since the original tour- it’s easy to forget how well-crafted and effective the show is. It disarms you with its audiences spellers, eccentric characters, and hilarious sample sentences in the first half, then makes the characters’ struggles and anxieties very real and heartfelt in the second. It takes its adolescent weirdos very seriously, much to its credit. There’s been a good amount of updating the book, from many new words to a re-conception of Mitch Mahoney to an impressive solving of a rubick’s cube.
The cast is perfection- from Justin Cooley’s endearingly odd Leaf to Autumn Best’s tightly wound Logainne. Jasmine Amy Rogers soars in a very different role from Boop- her Olive is heartbreaking without being pitiful, her loneliness undercut by her dorky love of language and instinctive kindness. “The I Love You Song” is the crown jewel of the score and Rogers, Matt Manuel, Lilli Cooper knock it out of the park. Cooper also shines here a great deal- her Rona is harder edged and less warm than Lisa Howard, but her casual bitchiness and air of self-importance work really well and are very funny.
It’s just such a charming production, a perfect antidote to everything going on in the world. The show celebrates these spelling nerds and wears its heart on its sleeve and in the hands of this cast you root for everyone to win. The audience reacted with audible disappointment to the eliminations, which to me shows how well the show builds these characters and how well these performers bring them to life.