It sound like Bill T. Jones' choreography could be a strong contender at the Tony Awards, which absolutely thrills me. It is so innovative and unlike anything Broadway has seen. I am beyond thrilled at these reviews! The two most difficult to please critics, John Simon and Clive Barnes, gave the show raves! It's surreal. I can't wait to see the box office jump.
Some quotes in reviews that stood out to me:
Theatermania: Sheik's absolutely haunting and often breathtaking score still outshine Sater's poetic lyrics, and many of these songs clearly stand up to repeated listening. What's most remarkable about Sheik is his adeptness at so many musical styles, from the girl-group harmonies of "Mama Who Bore Me" to the Elvis Costello-like rock of Mortiz's "Don't Do Sadness" to the art-rock balladry of "Whispering."
NY Sun: The result is, with apologies to Christine Ebersole and Mary Louise Wilson's masterful pas de deux of codependency in "Grey Gardens," the musical event of the year.
During the haunting opening song, " Mama Who Bore Me," Wendla introduces virtually the show's only piece of choreography, a swaying, sinuous, totemic series of movements from modern-dance icon Bill T. Jones. It is both provocative and protective — an ideal expression of adolescence — and it resurfaces throughout the musical: fast and slow, tentative and furious, triumphant and terrified.
Philadelphia Inquirer: The cast is remarkable. The young Melchior, whose progressive thoughts make him an attractive radical among the girls and a role model for the boys, is played by a 21-year-old from Lancaster, Pa., named Jonathan Groff. Blessed with a strong baritone, great looks and a magnetic presence, Groff is adorable in his innocence. The girl he falls in love with is named Wendla, played by Lea Michele, a wide-eyed, rich-lipped beauty who sings with the sweetest longing.
"Winning a Tony this year is like winning Best Attendance in third grade: no one will care but the winner and their mom."
-Kad
"I have also met him in person, and I find him to be quite funny actually. Arrogant and often misinformed, but still funny."
-bjh2114 (on Michael Riedel)
Updated On: 12/11/06 at 12:29 PM