I saw the show this weekend and really enjoyed it.
It had some flaws, but overall it was a nice production.
Stefanie gave a very nice performance; her voice was good, though it switched from chest to head all over the place, particularly in “With One Look.” And you could tell that she backed off some of the money notes. (It was a Saturday Matinee, so there are any number of reasons for that.) But she acted the part very well, keeping Norma on the more human side of the simply insane caricature that she often can become.
The Joe was decent, though you could tell he was reaching a bit for his highest notes. His mid-range singing was perfect, and he acted the part well.
The Betty was truly the star of the show, she was excellent every time she came on stage and made the show better whenever she appeared.
Max acted it fairly well, but varied between cartoonish and too stiff.
The chorus was excellent throughout, with solid harmonies and nice cameo performances. (and some drop dead gorgeous members whose hotness verged on distracting)
Tech had some issues, some obvious missed cues, and the opening number was garbled and hard to follow while they balanced between all of the mikes.
The set used sliding Art-deco panels to create most of the scenes outside the mansion, and were nicely effective. However the Mansion itself could have been done better. There was an odd outcropping on the railing of the staircase that looked very tacked on. (and when Joe threw his coat on the rail, you could tell it was indeed tacked on to keep the coat from sliding off.) The color scheme was red and orange, but with art-deco design features that made it slightly disjointed, but not distractingly so.
The projections were effective, if a bit long at times.
Overall, I wouldn’t necessarily say that the show is worth the trip by itself, but Maine is beautiful and Ogunquit and the surrounding areas ARE worth a trip. And the Ogunquit Playhouse is a nice place to see a show with a great history and a casual feel. So if you are planning on going to the beach anyway, why not make it Maine and grab tickets to the show while you are up there?
(apologies for using only character names, but I don't have the playbill in front of me)
Baritone in search of a role in a new musical...