Musicnut82 said: "TaffyDavenport said: "Well, that was spectacular. Spielberg's best film since 1993, and my personal favorite since The Color Purple in 1985. It's magical, and there isn't a single thing about it I would change."
Wow, that is a very bold statement, if you take into account that his filmography since 1993 includes: SPR, A.I., Minority Report, Munich and Lincoln. Personally I consider SPR, A.I. and Munich masterpieces, the rest can be argued from very good to good.
That aside, was it really that good eh? Without giving much spoilers, did you find some of the criticism that circulates valid? For e.g. Ansel Elgort is emotionally flat and doesn't have chemistry with Rachel. The film although technically perfect fails to trigger the emotions in the third act and feels flat.
Did you feel and saw any of that?
Thank you for your feedback in advance. Monday can't come soon enough for me!!
"
I thought my post was pretty clear. If there was nothing about it I would change, then, yes, I think it's really that good, and, no, I don't agree with the criticisms that are circulating. You're welcome to feel differently, but I thought it was better than anything he made after 1993, which includes the films you mentioned. They're great movies, but there's just something incredibly special about this one. Just my opinion.
Updated On: 12/9/21 at 09:27 PM