I finally saw this Wednesday evening. It was a dream come true, and here are a few observations:
1. I didn't feel cheated at all by this being "semi-staged." It was a beautiful show and Lonny Price had many elegant solutions to the staging challenges.
2.Like many others, I've never been keen on the score as a whole. I liked the Norma/Max stuff, but didn't care to listen much to the rest. But seeing it in context of the show, with energetic performers putting the studio / Artie's party scenes over, and that orchestra creating a plush, purple wall of sound, I enjoyed the score from start to finish. I think folks have been to hard on it, mainly because it's cool to bash ALW. It's not a masterpiece, but it's a wonderful show.
3. The three supporting principals were great, even though I had no idea who they were. People have not given Michael Xavier enough credit. People come to see Norma, but Joe carries the show. I feel like Xavier was like Atlas Shrugged, holding the show on his shoulders.
4. Glenn sounded rusty, even flat at first, but she nailed the money note at the end of "With One Look", and from there she was off to the races. I really appreciated how her vocal inflections have changed over the years, like the eerie little girl voice she uses for "when he scorned me I knew he had to die... " On the other board, someone who attended the same performance I did is putting forth a conspiracy theory that some of Glenn's notes are being piped in! I think this actually a testament to how strong her voice is these days.