Posted: 11/25/15 at 6:50am
Just posting after a brief trip to NY where I was fortunate enough to have tickets to last Friday's performance. I had been blown away by the production at the Menier and very interested to see how this had taken up a new life on Broadway, particularly having read everyone's comments on the Board.
Firstly, the set. The Menier was, as here, stripped wood and chairs on pegs. However, the audience was seated on three sides. This made for a real intimacy (but one drawback being the inability to hide your tears from those sitting opposite) and I was keen to see how that would translate to a bigger house. I felt that Doyle managed this perfectly and what it lost in intimacy, the height of the set added something very special to the production. The more functional/practical aspects of the chairs at the Menier were maintained, but I felt they also worked on a very different level here. Reaching up to the heavens, they spoke of the ages, ancestors, family, memory and the passing of time; generations of Celies have sat on those chairs and lived and worked and struggled and now, here she is - the representation of all those who had gone before her.
This production represents Doyle at his best - everything created and suggested before us. Sheets, baskets and chairs taking on different lives; everything else stripped away to leave these characters telling their story. Nettie, present at key moments keeps the focus on sisterhood, memory and connection which then, of course, makes the final moments of the show overwhelming.
Regarding the performances, this is truly a company show. Doyle gives everyone their moment; every single member of the cast makes their impression - and the vocals were wonderful. I really liked Hudson; for a Broadway debut, this is an excellent vehicle. She makes an impact without having the responsibility of carrying the show. Whilst not a great actress, her throwaway delivery served the character well and she is given the opportunity to show off that voice whilst maintaining great control. This cast must give her great confidence; she is given a very safe place to fall and I really think she will learn and grow. I was moved by Danielle Brooks; excellent timing and a real honesty to her performance. She was genuinely overcome by the audience reaction at the curtain.
However, the evening really belongs to Erivo. She gives a sensational central performance taking everyone on her incredibly emotional journey. I found her performance literally overwhelming. Honest, raw, layered and with a true ability to connect with and hold an audience. There were moments when the audence held our collective breath. Vocally she is sensational - I have never heard a reaction mid-song like that to the simple line, 'I'm beautiful'. The wall of sound that went up at that point let her know she was just that - and the tears flowed. This is a peformance that has to be seen and treasured. To have seen her at the Menier was a joy; to have seen her on Broadway - a privilege.