I watched tonight, courtesy of a press friend with a screener code.
I have been upfront with the fact that I did not love the stage show.
I think the movie does the show absolutely no favors.
There have been very few major changes made for the adaptation, which results in a very long and dragging film, and only highlights the flaws of the book. Murphy inexplicably bathes almost every musical numbers in teal and magenta light, and his fetishization of wealth continues in his depiction of Edgewater, IN: this suburban town is loaded with huge new houses, a huge new school, and an enormous high-end mall from which the immaculate townsfolk get their clothes. Emma, who is consistently knocked for her style, is... exceptionally stylish.
The cast acquits itself... fine. There’s no real standout, to me. Corden’s casting remains somewhat baffling to me- he’s too young for the character as written. Kidman is having a lot of fun, but clearly uses a double and a lot of simplified choreography for “Zazz.” Meryl is giving almost a parody of Meryl: all of her actorly tics are on display and bigger than ever. I kind of forgot about Rannells when he wasn’t onscreen.
I can’t lay this solely at the feet of Murphy, but someone who has never had a great grasp on tonal shifts is not what this show needed.
"...everyone finally shut up, and the audience could enjoy the beginning of the Anatevka Pogram in peace."
Updated On: 11/29/20 at 10:23 PM