FancyNacy said: "I thought Tuck was amazing. The story is believable and ther peefomances given by Sarah, Carolee, Terrance, as well as the rest of the cast, are very impressive. I'm not sure why people have decided to get so negative about a piece of theatre that does an awesome job telling a story that deals with a very real life lesson. To me, I compare it to works like The Secret Garden, Big River, etc. which really allow you to compare the events in the story to events in your own life.
I have nothing against the other musicals being considered this season, but I think Tuck should be recognized for how the total package is delivered to the audience. The visuals are breathtaking and honestly some of the best work I have seen on the Broadway stage this season...it is so refreshing to see truly thoughtful work on the stage and I think the cast gives it every performance. I think that this is unexpected evening for Casey and people go into it expecting his usual deal, but I appreciate his ability to step outside the box and really deliver something that we have not seen in a while.
I think everyone can agree that while not perfect, Tuck Everlasting truly is a must see this season and really deserves the chance to be considered not only because of the amazing costumes and amazing performances by the star studded cast, but because it really shows a side of the creative team that we don't usually get to see/celebrate.
I, too, found it to be a lovely show, and I'm surprised at some of the negative reactions. I think the ballet at the end is stunningly beautiful and a total surprise. I'm rooting for this show to do well, and it will be very popular with young audiences -- it's sweet, yet thought-provoking. Such amazingly diverse shows in NYC right now. I saw "Dear Evan Hansen" tonight -- I have a feeling that is going to be big next year on Broadway. There's room for all kinds of shows. If "Tuck Everlasting" is too G-rated for you, try Evan.
"