I agree with the majority of the opinions here; the show is just fine. Inoffensive and not very memorable. The score is forgettable, and nobody wows in the cast because they're just not given a chance to (I did like Andrew Keenan-Bolger and Carolee Carmello the best.) There does seem like a lot of padding, and yet, I feel like nothing really happens and nothing is very developed. Almost every song had a similar theme or message.
Click Here To Toggle Spoiler Content
I was especially baffled by Winnie's sudden change-of-heart about drinking the water. Angus sings one song to her and all of a sudden she decides she wants to age and live out the rest of her life? It was such an abrupt 180.
The staging is fine. The choreography didn't bother me too much but I agree this show should've been treated like Violet, not a big, splashy musical.
A little swash, a bit of buckle - you'll love it more than bread.